The United Nations' highest court, the
International Court of Justice (ICJ), has delivered a historic ruling declaring
that the 2017 massacre and widespread sexual violence committed by Myanmar's
security forces against the Rohingya Muslim minority constituted
state-sponsored genocide. The ruling, issued seven years after the
Muslim-majority country of The Gambia filed the case, marks only the fourth time
since the Nazi Holocaust that an international court has determined that the
legal threshold for proving genocide has been met. However, it is the first
time in history that the court has held an entire state responsible for
genocide.
Reading out the verdict, Presiding Judge Yuji
Iwasawa said the court had concluded that Myanmar's security forces killed
thousands of Rohingya civilians, committed widespread sexual violence,
subjected children to extreme brutality and attacked Rohingya people fleeing
for their lives. The panel of judges
ruled that “the Republic of the Union of Myanmar committed genocide against the
Rohingya group in northern Rakhine State.” Meanwhile, Myanmar's government did
not immediately respond to a request for comment on the ruling.
Brutal Crimes by Myanmar's Military and a
Campaign of Hatred
In its ruling, the 15-member panel determined
that Myanmar's military had carried out mass killings of men and boys during
so-called clearance operations, committed widespread rape and sexual violence
against Rohingya women, and destroyed hundreds of villages by burning or
demolishing them. According to the judges, the military also systematically
spread hate speech and propaganda targeting the Rohingya population. The bench
stated that the only reasonable explanation for Myanmar's actions was that they
were intended to destroy a substantial part of the protected Rohingya group in
northern Rakhine State, meeting the legal criteria for genocide. The court's
ruling is final and cannot be appealed.
Compensation and Order for a Dignified Return
In a major legal victory for The Gambia, the
court held Myanmar responsible as a state for the genocide resulting from the
military campaign, which forced at least 700,000 Rohingya Muslims to flee the
Buddhist-majority country. The smoke rising from Myanmar behind Rohingya
refugees who crossed the Bangladesh-Myanmar border by boat through the Bay of
Bengal on September 11, 2017, and arrived at Shah Porir Dwip in Bangladesh,
stood as a stark testament to the atrocities. The court ordered Myanmar to
compensate Rohingya victims for the violations committed, with the amount to be
determined at a later stage. It further stated that Rohingya people displaced
as a result of Myanmar's unlawful actions should be allowed to return to their
ancestral homes safely and with dignity, while separated families should be
reunited.
Potential Impact on the Gaza Genocide Case and
Other Proceedings
Genocide is rarely established in international
courts, largely because prosecutors must prove the specific intent to destroy,
in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group. The ICJ's ruling is expected to have implications
far beyond Myanmar, including for the case filed by South Africa against Israel
in 2023, accusing it of committing genocide in Gaza. This is the court's first major ruling in more
than a decade on the application of the 1948 Genocide Convention. Legal experts
are expected to examine the decision closely to understand how the judges
determined state responsibility for alleged international crimes. It is worth
noting that both Israel and Myanmar deny the genocide allegations, maintaining
that their armed forces were responding lawfully to attacks by armed groups.
Jurisdiction and Powers of the International
Court of Justice
Before this ruling, international courts had recognized
genocide on only three occasions: the 1994 genocide in Rwanda, the 1995
massacre in Srebrenica, Bosnia, and the atrocities committed by the Khmer Rouge
in Cambodia in the late 1970s. Although the International Court of Justice
(ICJ), which settles disputes between states and rules on alleged violations of
international treaties, issues legally binding and final judgments, its powers
to enforce them are extremely limited. The
ICJ is distinct from the International Criminal Court (ICC), which prosecutes
individuals for war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide and has the
authority to impose prison sentences.