A group of US taxpayers and human rights lawyers
has submitted evidence to the International Criminal Court (ICC), urging its
prosecutor to seek arrest warrants against US President Donald Trump, Secretary
of State Marco Rubio and other senior American officials over allegations of
aiding and abetting genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity committed
by Israel in Gaza. The submission, filed with the ICC Office of the Prosecutor
on November 11, contains more than 500 pieces of evidence, including witness
statements, sworn affidavits and documents detailing US military, financial and
diplomatic support for Israel. Organized by the Taxpayers Alliance against
Genocide (TAAG), the initiative seeks to hold American officials
accountable for their alleged role in enabling crimes committed by Israeli
authorities in Gaza.
Human rights lawyer Maria Kari, legal co-counsel
for TAAG, told TRT World: “For many of us, it has been easy to turn a blind eye
to what is being done every day using our dollars, in our name. But our clients
never looked away.” Kari said TAAG
members had spent a year compiling evidence against Trump and Rubio, arguing
that the alleged crimes could not have been committed without the Trump
administration's unconditional and seemingly limitless provision of money,
weapons and diplomatic support for Israel's occupation. “We are turning to the ICC because we have
tried everything at home; we have filed lawsuits in domestic courts, knocked on
the doors of every member of Congress and taken part in peaceful protests,” she
said. According to Kari, the submission
also seeks to represent more than 64 children who have been killed or injured
in Gaza. The decision to approach the ICC in The Hague follows years of
unsuccessful efforts to hold US officials accountable through domestic courts.
One such effort was the 2023 case of DCIP v.
Biden, in which a group of Palestinian Americans sued then-President Joe
Biden, Secretary of State Antony Blinken and the US defence secretary, accusing
them of complicity in genocide and failing to prevent it. Although a judge
dismissed the case in January 2024, the court said Israel's conduct was
plausibly characterised as genocide and urged the Biden administration to
reconsider its “unconditional support” for Israel. “In other words, the courts
said that foreign policy decisions are the responsibility of the president and
Congress, not the judiciary,” Kari said.
She added that other lawsuits brought by
Palestinian Americans had also been dismissed on procedural grounds. Kari
recalled receiving her first request for assistance from an American citizen
trapped in Gaza nearly three years ago. The Biden administration initially
refused to evacuate her client, but the woman and approximately 80 other
Americans were eventually evacuated after Kari's legal team filed a lawsuit
against the government. Other clients, however, were not as fortunate. Mofi
Harah, from Dallas, was killed by a missile that, according to Kari, had been
purchased with US taxpayers' money. Two other clients, Barak and Hashem Alaga,
both from Chicago, were imprisoned in Israel while waiting for assistance from
the US government.
According to Terry Lodge, a lawyer and legal
co-counsel for the initiative, these cases highlight the human cost of the US
government's failure to protect its citizens and hold American officials
accountable. “Taxpayers Alliance Against Genocide began with a lawsuit,” Lodge
told TRT World. He said the organization was established in September 2024,
when activists across several counties in Northern California came together to
file a class-action lawsuit against their members of Congress, accusing them of
unlawfully using taxpayers' money to finance genocide. “In February 2025, the
judge dismissed a similar case for essentially the same reasons, ruling that
the court could not intervene in what it considered a political question,” he
said. Lodge added that TAAG, alongside other groups across the United States,
had also protested against their elected representatives' votes to continue
funding what they described as genocide. “Our representatives have ignored us
or, when they have met with us, reassured us before voting in ways that have
continued the flow of arms and weapons to Israel,” he said.
The initiative comes as Trump has intensified
pressure on international institutions. In February 2025, he signed an
executive order authorizing sanctions against individuals and entities involved
in ICC investigations targeting US citizens or allies. Since then, his
administration has imposed sanctions on ICC officials and Francesca Albanese,
the UN Special Rapporteur on the occupied Palestinian territories. Kari said
that after repeatedly encountering political obstacles to their efforts in the
United States, the group submitted a report to the UN Human Rights Council as
part of its review of the country's human rights record. “The US response was
that the Trump administration announced it would withdraw from the Universal
Periodic Review (UPR) process. This was the first time in history that a state
had refused to participate in such a review,” she said.
“The ICC is designed to step in precisely in
situations like the one we have faced in the United States over the past three
years. We are not only major enablers of this genocide; we are also governed by
a system that is unwilling or unable to hold its leaders accountable,” she
added. The submission alleges that Washington has violated its obligations
under the American Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Man and binding
principles of international law by enabling human rights violations beyond its
borders. Lawyers also faced challenges in documenting potential international
crimes as the destruction in Gaza continued. Investigators had to contend with
the loss of physical evidence, restricted access to locations and the deaths of
potential witnesses.
Journalists, who have played a crucial role in
documenting the attacks, have also paid a heavy price. According to Gaza's
Government Media Office, at least 262 Palestinian journalists have been killed and
another 433 injured in Israeli attacks since 2023. Medical workers treating the
wounded and civilians trying to obtain food for their families have also been
among those killed. Delivering a keynote address at the launch of the
initiative, UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese described the submission
as an important effort to defend the international legal order against attempts
by powerful states to undermine it. Praising TAAG for demonstrating the courage
to take action, she said: “International law is the last peaceful tool we have
to confront injustice and pave the way forward. The legal instruments exist;
they are peaceful instruments, and many people lack the political courage to
use them.”
Albanese also criticised Washington's attacks on
the ICC, the United Nations and the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine
Refugees (UNRWA), arguing that they reflected a broader effort to weaken
institutions capable of challenging powerful governments. The evidence is now
before the ICC Office of the Prosecutor. TAAG's legal team acknowledges that
the process could face significant political and legal obstacles, particularly
given pressure from Washington. “Politically, we believe the court is facing
enormous pressure from a small number of governments, particularly the United
States,” Kari said. She added: “We believe such pressure is not only
politically inappropriate but also legally unacceptable and a violation of the Rome
Statute, which should not go unpunished.” “Although we recognize the political
pressure, we hope the prosecutor and the court will have the courage to reject
it and assess the evidence solely in light of the elements of the alleged
crimes and the evidentiary standards established by the Rome Statute,” she
said.